Teaching Portfolio - Coral Sheldon-Hess

Assistant Professor of Computer Information Technology & Data Analytics

Information Related to Enhancing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion

In seeking to enhance diversity, equity, and inclusion at CCAC, I try to adhere to the three principles of social justice as applied to open education that were identified by Sarah R. Lambert in her 2018 article "Changing our (Dis)Course: A Distinctive Social Justice Aligned Definition of Open Education"(1): redistributive, recognitive, and representational justice.

Redistributive Justice

The definition given by Lambert, who in turn cites a 1971 article by J. Rawls, is "allocation of material or human resources towards those who by circumstance have less." My attempts at redistributive justice in the classroom include my

  • use of open educational resources (OERs) and low-cost textbooks (under $40) in lieu of expensive textbooks in CIT-125, DAT-202, DAT-204, and as a supplement to a textbook in DAT-119;
  • attempts to downgrade textbooks from "required" to "recommended," whenever possible (CIT-100), which creates extra work for me (e.g. scanning or re-typing any problems from the book that I might want to use) but gives students more flexibility in how they choose to spend their educational dollars;
  • commitment to making sure every required or recommended textbook is available in the Library as a course reserve (CIT-100, CIT-115, CIT-145, CIT-215, and DAT-119) (course reserves are not offered right now, due to the pandemic);
  • colleagues’ and my agreement to use the same textbook for multiple courses in a progression (DAT-119 and DAT-129);
  • commitment to avoiding expensive auto-graders and other publisher add-ons that the students are expected to pay for, but that are designed to save time for faculty; and
  • refusal to require students to have cameras on in synchronous courses.

The last item, above, is well established as a necessity for an equitable and inclusive classroom. I take it one step further, encouraging students who prefer not to use the microphone to use text chat, instead; this actively includes people with certain neuratypicalities, people with children or other sources of sound in their home environment that they may not want to share with the class, people who cannot speak, shy people, and people without microphones in the class discussion. I read out or summarize chat comments, for the benefit of anyone watching the recording or keeping chat minimized to avoid distraction.

I also encourage my colleagues to adopt an equity mindset in their online courses, as you can see from my Center for Teaching and Learning presentation slides.

Recognitive Justice

Lambert defines recognitive justice as "recognition and respect for cultural and gender difference." Examples of recognitive justice include "Socio-cultural diversity in the ... curriculum. Inclusion of images, case studies, and knowledges of women, First Nations people and whomever is marginalised in any particular national, regional or learning context. Recognition of diverse views and experiences as legitimate within open assignments and feedback."

I teach computer courses, where the majority of my students, sometimes the entirety of the students in a course, appear to be white, male, cisgender, straight, and able-bodied. Having the course taught by a non-binary (but assigned female at birth) queer person with disabilities could be, in itself, a very small measure of recognitive justice in this environment, but it is far from enough. I start the semester with a pre-course survey; and in it, I ask for students to tell me what name they would like me to call them by and to—optionally, as is the current best practice for this—tell me what pronouns they would like me to use in referring to them. On the day we go over our syllabus, I emphasize my students’ right to accommodations for any disabilities they might have and make it clear that I am not only happy, but also legally required, to accommodate them.

In the "introduction to computers" lecture at the beginning of programming courses and interspersed throughout the semester in more general computer courses like CIT-100 and CIT-115, I call out the place that Black, Indigenous, and Person of Color (BIPOC); LGBTQ+ individuals; people with disabilities; and women outside of those categories have played in the history of computers and touch very briefly on why those roles, huge though they are, have sometimes seemed to shrink over time and been downplayed in the public consciousness. In my Web Development course, several of the pages I ask students to create are centered on historical BIPOC women in tech such as Melba Roy Mouton and Mary Golda Ross; students also make a page about Admiral Grace Hopper.

Because the risk of impostor syndrome and stereotype threat are markedly increased in BIPOC and white women in tech, I make sure to call out both mental tendencies to the entire class, without calling out who is most likely to fall prey to them, and to remind students regularly that we all struggle; it may look like other people have an easier time of things because we only see their successes, but this is not true. In an attempt to more actively tamp down impostor syndrome, I also encourage everyone to ask their questions in the class Slack channel, to help everyone see that nobody is alone in struggling with the material or having questions. Finally, I allow students to be experts on their own experiences, and I welcome their insights as they relate to (especially, but not only) data analytics and prejudicial decisions by algorithms.

Representational Justice

Lambert’s definition of representational justice is that it "involves equitable representation and political voice" (with several external citations), with examples of "Self-determination of marginalised people and groups to speak for themselves, and not have their stories told by others" and "Facilitation to ensure quiet and minority views have equal air-time in open online discussions." Of the three principles, this is probably where I need to work the hardest over the coming years. I share readings and videos from as diverse a set of creators as possible, but the bulk of my textbooks are written by white, seemingly cisgender, men. Moving further away from textbooks and into use of OERs is likely to be helpful, but I must remain cognizant of who put together a given resource and what biases it might contain—and whom it leaves out.

In the context of class discussions, I am aware that teachers tend to call on male students significantly more often than female students.(2) More recent articles have suggested that similar preferences may exist for white, straight, and/or able-bodied students. Like all expressions of implicit bias, the first step is to be aware of a tendency toward this behavior in ourselves and others. The second step is to fight it, actively, and I try to do this in my classroom, without tokenizing anyone or calling out perceived differences. I believe we can all do better on this front, though, and I continue to work on it. In my remote-synchronous courses, because I give as much space for students to use text chat as the microphone, I do see somewhat more equitable participation across gender lines; I also suspect that allowing text chat and encouraging people to ask questions on Slack after class is helpful in encouraging people with certain types of neurodiversity to participate more equitably, as well.

References:

  1. Changing our (Dis)Course: A Distinctive Social Justice Aligned Definition of Open Education. Journal of Learning for Development, 5(3), 225-244.
  2. American Association of University Women, How Schools Shortchange Girls: A Study of Major Findings on Girls and Education, Marlowe & Company: New York, 1992. ISBN: 1-56924-821-4.